This case examines whether an organization qualifies as a non-profit organization for the purposes of immunity under Wis. Stat. § 895.52, “the recreational immunity statute.”
Some background: In 2002, Elizabeth Callejas De La Trinidad and Marisol Aguilar-Torres drowned while at a picnic at Halter Wildlife, a hunting club in Pleasant Prairie. The plaintiffs, the girls’ parents and the administrators of their estates, sued Halter, its insurance carrier, and the on-duty lifeguard.
The defendants moved for summary judgment, claiming recreational immunity. The circuit court granted the motion. The plaintiffs appealed, and the Court of Appeals affirmed [unpublished opinion].
The Court of Appeals said the only issue presented was whether Halter was a non-profit organization as defined in § 895.52 (1) (c).
The Court of Appeals noted that Halter’s articles of incorporation identify it as a non-profit corporation, but the plaintiffs argue it is not because it was organized under statutes that control “for profit” corporations, and it has shareholders.
In asking the Supreme Court to review the case, the plaintiffs argue the essential characteristic of non-profits is that they cannot distribute their profits or net earnings to their directors, officers or members. They contend money raised from holding picnics had the effect of reducing dues for Halter’s members.
The defendants argue the case does not present a question of corporate organization – only whether Halter is a non-profit organization under the recreational immunity statute. From Kenosha County.
Pages
Law and Policy aggregators:
Wednesday, May 21, 2008
Review granted in 'De La Trinidad v. Capitol Indemnity'
The Wisconsin Supreme Court has granted review in this case. (2007AP45)