Friday, August 29, 2008

Analysis: 'Stuart v. Weisflog's Showroom Gallery, Inc.'

[Terry J. Booth on Stuart v. Weisflog's Showroom Gallery, Inc., 2008 WI 86 (2005AP1287)]

Weisflog’s Showroom Gallery, Inc., (Weisflog) contracted with the Stuarts (Stuart) to design and build an addition to their home. Several years after the construction was completed, defects in the design and construction of the home were discovered. Those defects had led to damages to the addition. Stuart sued Weisflog for the costs to repair those damages.

Stuart alleged that their damages were caused by Weisflog’s negligence. They also claimed that their damages were caused by misrepresentations under the Home Improvement Trade Practices Act, codified as Wis. Admin. Code Ch. ATCP 110.

American Family Mutual Insurance Company (American Family) had issued a liability insurance policy to Weisflog. American Family provided a defense for Weisflog under a reservation of rights. American Family then moved for summary judgment dismissal from any duty to indemnify or defend Weisflog. Among other grounds, American Family argued that the ATCP 110 claim was not an occurrence under the policy. The trial court denied American Family’s motion.

The denial of American Family’s summary judgment motion was affirmed by the court of appeals. In doing so, the court of appeals declared that statutory misrepresentation claims under ATCP 110 are not misrepresentations which are subject to Everson v. Lorenz, 2005 WI 51, 280 Wis. 2d 1, 695 N.W.2d 298. In arriving at that conclusion, the court suggested that statutory misrepresentation claims under Wis. Stat. §100.18, were also not subject to Everson. The court stated that statutory misrepresentation claims under ATCP 110 and Wis. Stat. §100.18 were intent neutral, unlike the common law misrepresentation claims that were addressed in Everson.

The supreme court reversed the decisions of the trial court and court of appeals. The court found that ATCP 110 claims described volitional conduct which was subject to Everson and which did not constitute an “occurrence” as that term is typically defined in commercial liability insurance policies. In doing so, it also suggested that Wis. Stat. §100.18 misrepresentation claims also describe volitional conduct which is subject to Everson, and which is not an “occurrence” under typical commercial liability insurance policies.

PRINCIPLES ESTABLISHED AND FUTURE CONSIDERATIONS

1. The continued vitality of Everson was affirmed.

2. Everson is applicable to ATCP 110 claims.

3. Everson is probably applicable to Wis. Stat. §100.18 claims.

4. The scope of what constitutes a volitional act for the purpose of applying Everson remains unsettled. Possibilities include the following:
A. An act is volitional if the intended harm is accomplished.

B. An act is volitional if the intended act is accomplished.

C. An act is volitional if the wrongfulness of the act is known.

D. The act is volitional if the conduct intended is accomplished and the conduct is, knowingly or unknowingly wrongful.

E. The act is volitional if the conduct intended is accomplished, and the result of the act is known to be wrongful.

[The preceding is from Mr. Booth's August 14, 2008 presentation at the Civil Trial of Wisconsin Summer Conference, Wisconsin Dells, and is used with his permission.]