Dissent by Justice Roggensack, with Justices Prosser and Ziegler
I write in dissent because: (1) Rule 801.54 is inadequate and misleading in regard to addressing tribal court concurrent subject matter jurisdiction, which jurisdiction is extremely limited in scope when nonmembers are parties to the action; (2) Rule 801.54 impermissibly alters the substantive rights of tribal members, as well as nonmembers, contrary to the provisions of Wis. Stat. § 751.12(1) (2005-06),[3] which limits the court's rule-making power; (3) Rule 801.54 undermines federal and state constitutional and statutory rights of litigants; and (4) a majority of the court has pushed this rule-change through before the end of the 2007-08 term of the court, even though the court has been presented with no information about the substantive rights and civil procedures that are available in tribal courts.
Hearing audio January 8, 2008
Petition filed July 24, 2007 by A. John Voelker, Director of State Courts
In the matter of the petition to create a rule governing the discretionary transfer of cases to tribal court (07-11)