Sunday, October 12, 2008

Antitrust Follies

As serious people go about serious business, the FTC is wasting taxpayer money investigating
whether a merger of Whole Foods and Wild Oats, two "organic" food stores, would violate the obsolete (at best) and unconstitutional antitrust laws.

Talk about a fools' errand. It is unfathomable how either store, much less a combination of them, could present any anticompetitive threat. Both are already overpriced, and socially irresponsible.

Suppose all agricultural land was converted to "organic" farming. The result -- massive food shortages -- would result in literally billions dying of starvation. Even those well off enough not to starve would still see their food budgets triple.

Of course, there are still Malthusian remnants among us who would enjoy this, but I am willing to accept the average "organic" food shopper as simply misguided, rather than genuinely evil.

Ultimately, though, these grocery stores fulfill no need whatsoever except to give insecure people, who have more dollars than sense, a false sense of superiority over the masses who are grateful for the agricultural revolution, and don't have the luxury of renouncing its great benefits.

A good analogy for the FTC's actions is to imagine if, back in the 1970s, the FTC were to block a merger of Erhard Seminar Training and Lifeworks (for you young attorneys, those were cults back then).

Like "organic" food stores, these cults made alot of money preying on insecure rich people. Ultimately, they died out, because they charged people alot of money, while providing nothing of any intrinsic value.

Ultimately, "organic" food stores will die out for the same reason, with or without any action on the part of the socialists who still believe that antitrust law is both constitutional and sound policy.