Tuesday, October 14, 2008

Synopsis of 'State v. Gajewski'

The Wisconsin Supreme Court on September 11, 2008 granted the petition to review the Court of Appeals decision in this case (2007AP1849-CR), see Review granted in 'State v. Gajewski'.
In this third-degree sexual assault case, the Supreme Court has been asked to review how the law should have been applied to claims of ineffective assistance of counsel by the defendant, Jordan L. Gajewski.

Some background: A jury found Gajewski guilty of third-degree sexual assault. The female victim testified that after attending a party on May 8, 2005, she spent the night at a friend's house, as did the defendant, a high-school classmate the victim said she did not know well.

The victim testified at trial that during the night she woke up to find the defendant kissing her and removing her clothing. She said he then had intercourse with her. She testified that she told the defendant to stop and that he eventually did stop and went back to sleep. Two other people were sleeping in the same room at the time, and two other friends of the victim were in the house. None of the other people awakened, and the victim did not yell for help. The victim reported the assault on May 18, 2005.

Sentence was withheld and Gajewski was ordered to serve five years probation with 12 months in jail, with Huber privileges, as a condition. The sentence was stayed pending appeal. The defendant filed a post-conviction motion alleging newly discovered evidence and ineffective assistance of counsel. The newly discovered evidence consisted of a witness saying that he overheard the victim making a statement that "it never happened; I just did it to piss him off" the day after the trial ended. The circuit court concluded the comment the witness overheard was so vague that there was no reasonable probability that a different result would be reached at trial if the jury had heard the statement.

With respect to the ineffective assistance of counsel claim, the postconviction court said it agreed with the state's position that the defendant was bringing up information post-trial that he never conveyed to his attorney. The court said it did not find counsel's performance to be outside the range of the professionally competent assistance. The defendant appealed, and the Court of Appeals reversed and remanded.

A decision from the Supreme Court would help to develop and clarify the law on how ineffective assistance of counsel issues are to be analyzed. From Marathon County.